Oak tree chopped down by couple because of falling acorns

A couple have been slapped with a hefty fine after chopping down an oak tree without permission. Andrew and Donna Phipps admitted to felling the tree without council consent when they appeared in court.

In April 2023, the couple took down the healthy oak, estimated to be between 80 and 100 years old, without giving prior notice to Forest of Dean District Council as required by law. The Phipps had sought permission from the council a year earlier but were denied.

The tree was situated on the rear boundary of their garden. They argued that it cast a shadow, required constant maintenance due to falling leaves, branches and acorns, and posed a risk to their property during storms.

On a whim, they decided to fell the tree when a man offering his services approached them. Before its removal, the tree was visible from public viewpoints and was considered a significant part of the landscaping.

Cheltenham Magistrates' Courtordered Mr and Mrs Phipps, of The Paddocks in Coleford, to pay a fine of £1,760, costs of £2,085 and a victim surcharge of £704, bringing the total amount they must pay to £4,549, reports Gloucestershire Live.

Cllr Sid Phelps, Cabinet Member for Planning Policy, has emphasised the council's commitment to upholding planning regulations, especially concerning tree felling, for the benefit of the local environment. He stated: "As a council it is our duty to ensure that planning regulations, particularly those around tree felling, are adhered to for the benefit of the local environment. Hundreds of people every year follow the correct process, but sadly this has not been the case at this location."

He further added, regarding the role of the Enforcement Team: "As part of their role, the Enforcement Team helps to ensure that incidents of tree felling are investigated and that those who do not comply with the correct legislation are held accountable."

Cllr Phelps also referred to a recent court decision as evidence of the council's determination to enforce regulations: "The verdict should stand as testament to this. Planning and tree felling needs to be carried out in the correct manner, with the correct permissions and if, as in this case, it isn't, our Counter Fraud and Enforcement team will enforce it."

The successful prosecution was a joint effort by Forest of Dean District Council's planning enforcement team, the Council's Counter Fraud and Enforcement Unit (CFEU), and Legal Service.

For more details on Trees in conservation areas, residents can visit the Council's website.